CVA · CRR3 · Counterparty risk

BA-CVA vs SA-CVA under CRR3: which approach fits?

· 8 min read · Everix team

Short answer: under CRR3, most banks will compute CVA risk capital with the basic approach (BA-CVA), which needs only SA-CCR exposures, supervisory risk weights and, optionally, credit default swap hedges. The standardised approach (SA-CVA) needs supervisory permission, a regulatory CVA model and monthly CVA sensitivities, and pays off mainly for banks that actively hedge the market-risk side of CVA. Small derivative users can use the simplified approach instead.

CRR3 (Regulation (EU) 2024/1623) replaced the EU's CVA framework from 1 January 2025 with the approaches the Basel Committee finalised in Basel III: Finalising post-crisis reforms (December 2017), now chapter MAR50 of the Basel Framework. The rules sit in CRR Articles 381 to 386.

The three approaches

Who can use it
Simplified (Art. 385)
Institutions meeting the Art. 273a(2) conditions (derivative business ≤ 5% of total assets and ≤ EUR 100 million) or permitted to use the original exposure method
BA-CVA (Art. 384)
Any institution
SA-CVA (Art. 383)
Only with competent authority permission
Inputs
Simplified (Art. 385)
Counterparty credit risk RWEA
BA-CVA (Art. 384)
SA-CCR (or IMM) exposure per netting set, effective maturity, counterparty sector and rating
SA-CVA (Art. 383)
CVA from a regulatory CVA model; delta and vega sensitivities of CVA and hedges
Formula
Simplified (Art. 385)
CCR RWEA ÷ 12.5
BA-CVA (Art. 384)
Supervisory risk weights aggregated across counterparties with ρ = 50%; optional hedge recognition
SA-CVA (Art. 383)
Sensitivities × risk weights, aggregated by bucket and risk class (delta + vega)
Hedges recognised
Simplified (Art. 385)
None
BA-CVA (Art. 384)
Single-name CDS (counterparty, legally related or same sector and region) and index CDS
SA-CVA (Art. 383)
Hedges of counterparty credit spread and of the exposure component (e.g. interest rate, FX)
Can be combined
Simplified (Art. 385)
No — exclusive
BA-CVA (Art. 384)
Yes, with SA-CVA
SA-CVA (Art. 383)
Yes, with BA-CVA

Article 382a(3) allows BA-CVA and SA-CVA side by side on a permanent basis, by counterparty, by netting set or even within a netting set under conditions. The simplified approach cannot be mixed with either.

BA-CVA in more detail

Article 384 has two versions:

  • Reduced (no hedges), used by institutions that do not recognise any eligible hedge. For each counterparty, a stand-alone charge is built from the supervisory risk weight, and for each netting set from the effective maturity, the SA-CCR exposure value and a supervisory discount factor. Counterparty charges are aggregated with a correlation ρ = 50%, which gives partial diversification. α = 1.4 appears among the terms.
  • Full (with hedges), for institutions that recognise eligible CDS hedges: BACVA_total = β · BACVA_unhedged + DS_CVA · (1 − β) · BACVA_hedged, with β = 0.25 and DS_CVA = 0.65. The β term keeps at least a quarter of the unhedged charge, so hedging can never remove all of it.

One drafting point worth noticing: in the Basel standard (MAR50.14 and MAR50.20), the 0.65 discount scalar multiplies both the reduced and the full versions. In the CRR's full formula as printed, DS_CVA multiplies only the hedged term. Check how your implementation reads Article 384 before comparing figures with a Basel-based tool.

Supervisory risk weights (Article 384, Table 1) depend on sector and credit quality:

CRR Article 384, Table 1. Unrated counterparties may be mapped from internal ratings with supervisory approval.

Central governments, central banks, MDBs, international organisations
Credit quality step 1–3
0.5%
Step 4–6 and unrated
2.0%
Regional or local authorities, public sector entities
Credit quality step 1–3
1.0%
Step 4–6 and unrated
4.0%
Financial sector entities, including public credit institutions and promotional lenders
Credit quality step 1–3
5.0%
Step 4–6 and unrated
12.0%
Basic materials, energy, industrials, agriculture, manufacturing, mining and quarrying
Credit quality step 1–3
3.0%
Step 4–6 and unrated
7.0%
Consumer goods and services, transportation and storage, administrative and support services
Credit quality step 1–3
3.0%
Step 4–6 and unrated
8.5%
Technology, telecommunications
Credit quality step 1–3
2.0%
Step 4–6 and unrated
5.5%
Health care, utilities, professional and technical activities
Credit quality step 1–3
1.5%
Step 4–6 and unrated
5.0%
Other sector
Credit quality step 1–3
5.0%
Step 4–6 and unrated
12.0%

Effective maturity follows Article 162, but it is not capped at five years; it is capped at the longest contractual remaining maturity in the netting set. Long-dated swaps with financial counterparties are where BA-CVA bites hardest.

SA-CVA in more detail

To get permission (Article 383(1)), an institution needs:

  1. a distinct unit responsible for managing and hedging CVA risk;
  2. a regulatory CVA model for each counterparty concerned (Article 383a);
  3. monthly CVA sensitivities to the relevant risk factors, and the same for eligible hedges;
  4. an independent risk control unit that designs the approach and reports on it monthly.

The regulatory CVA model is close to a front-office XVA engine: it simulates exposure by repricing every transaction across scenarios of the material market risk factors, derives default probabilities from credit spreads and market-consensus LGD, captures dependency between exposure and the counterparty's credit spread, and recognises margin agreements. The capital is then the sum of delta and vega charges across six risk classes: interest rate, counterparty credit spread, reference credit spread, equity, commodity and FX.

Which one fits?

Derivative business ≤ 5% of total assets and ≤ EUR 100 million
Likely fit
Simplified approach: one line, no new model
Moderate OTC book, no CVA desk, few or no CDS hedges
Likely fit
BA-CVA, reduced version
Credit hedges with single-name or index CDS
Likely fit
BA-CVA, full version
Active CVA desk hedging rates and FX risk of CVA; Monte Carlo XVA engine already in place
Likely fit
SA-CVA for the hedged perimeter, BA-CVA for the rest

The main reason to go for SA-CVA is hedge recognition. BA-CVA only recognises credit default swaps, so interest-rate and FX hedges of CVA attract market-risk capital instead of reducing CVA capital (Article 386(5)). SA-CVA recognises them. The price is model governance, monthly sensitivities and a permission process.

Data each approach needs

Counterparty credit risk RWEA
Simplified
Yes
BA-CVA
—
SA-CVA
—
SA-CCR (or IMM) exposure per netting set
Simplified
Indirectly
BA-CVA
Yes
SA-CVA
For scope and BA-CVA perimeter
Effective maturity per netting set
Simplified
—
BA-CVA
Yes
SA-CVA
—
Counterparty sector and credit quality step
Simplified
—
BA-CVA
Yes
SA-CVA
Yes (buckets)
CDS hedges: reference entity, notional, maturity
Simplified
—
BA-CVA
Full version only
SA-CVA
Yes
Simulated exposure paths and credit spreads
Simplified
—
BA-CVA
—
SA-CVA
Yes, monthly or more often
CVA sensitivities (delta, vega) by risk factor
Simplified
—
BA-CVA
—
SA-CVA
Yes, at least monthly

The step from BA-CVA to SA-CVA is less about formulas than about running a regulatory-grade XVA engine with daily data, model validation and independent control. Banks that already run a Monte Carlo CVA for accounting have most of the machinery. Banks that don't usually stay on BA-CVA.

Dates to keep in mind

  • 1 January 2025: CRR3 applies, including the new CVA framework. Unlike market risk, CVA capital was not postponed.
  • 10 July 2026: deadline for the EBA to submit draft technical standards on when CVA risk from fair-valued securities financing transactions is material (Article 382(6)).
  • 1 January 2027: the FRTB market-risk rules apply. They matter for CVA because hedges that are not eligible CVA hedges fall under market-risk capital (Article 386(5)).

Scope matters as much as method

Article 382 excludes, among others, transactions with qualifying CCPs, with non-financial counterparties below the EMIR clearing threshold, certain intragroup transactions, and counterparties that receive a 0% risk weight under Articles 114(4) and 115(2). The Article 382(4) exclusions may be brought back into scope under Article 382(4a). Article 382(4b) requires calculation and reporting for transactions excluded under paragraph 4. The separate QCCP and qualifying client-clearing exclusions are in paragraph 3. Fair-valued securities financing transactions are in scope where their CVA risk is material.

Where Everix fits

Everix has run Monte Carlo XVA in production since 2018, with exposure profiles per netting set and allocation to the trade, and computes SA-CCR exposures validated against the BCBS examples. Those are the two inputs that BA-CVA and SA-CVA rely on. A packaged BA-CVA or SA-CVA capital report is not part of the product today; if you need one, talk to us through the design-partner programme. Background: CVA, DVA, FVA and MVA explained and the SA-CCR worked example.

Sources: Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 as amended by Regulation (EU) 2024/1623, Articles 273a and 381 to 386 (consolidated text of 1 January 2025); Basel Framework, MAR50; BCBS d424. General information, not regulatory advice.

The Everix note

Get the next article by email

IFR, CRR3, SIMM changes and AI-ready risk data. Roughly monthly, double opt-in.

By subscribing, you ask for the Everix note. Confirm by email; unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Questions about your own portfolio?

Talk to the quants and engineers behind Everix — 30 minutes to check the fit.