Short answer: K-NPR measures the market risk of your positions with the CRR's market-risk approaches. K-CMG instead uses the margin your clearing member calls: the third-highest daily total margin of the last three months, times 1.3. K-CMG needs competent authority permission and only fits firms whose business is essentially cleared and margined trading. Everyone else uses K-NPR.
Both are Risk-to-Market K-factors under the Investment Firms Regulation. Article 21 says the RtM requirement is either K-NPR or K-CMG, and Article 23 allows K-CMG for all cleared positions or on a portfolio basis. A firm can therefore use K-CMG for a cleared portfolio and K-NPR for the rest.
Side by side
| K-NPR | K-CMG | |
|---|---|---|
| Legal basis | IFR Art. 22 | IFR Art. 23 |
| What it measures | Market risk of trading-book positions, plus non-trading-book FX and commodity positions (Art. 21(4)) | Total margin required by the clearing member |
| Formula | CRR standardised approach, FRTB-SA or internal models | 3rd-highest daily total margin over the preceding 3 months × 1.3 |
| Permission | None for the standardised approach | Competent authority must allow it; regular review of the margin model |
| Scope | All trading-book positions not under K-CMG | All positions subject to clearing, or whole portfolios that are cleared or margined |
| Data you need | Positions, prices, and for FRTB-SA, sensitivities | Daily margin calls from the clearing member |
| Exposure to FRTB (2027) | Yes, through the CRR cross-reference | No |
| Effect on SNI (Class 3) status | Any non-zero NPR rules out SNI | Any non-zero CMG rules out SNI |
- K-NPR
- IFR Art. 22
- K-CMG
- IFR Art. 23
- K-NPR
- Market risk of trading-book positions, plus non-trading-book FX and commodity positions (Art. 21(4))
- K-CMG
- Total margin required by the clearing member
- K-NPR
- CRR standardised approach, FRTB-SA or internal models
- K-CMG
- 3rd-highest daily total margin over the preceding 3 months × 1.3
- K-NPR
- None for the standardised approach
- K-CMG
- Competent authority must allow it; regular review of the margin model
- K-NPR
- All trading-book positions not under K-CMG
- K-CMG
- All positions subject to clearing, or whole portfolios that are cleared or margined
- K-NPR
- Positions, prices, and for FRTB-SA, sensitivities
- K-CMG
- Daily margin calls from the clearing member
- K-NPR
- Yes, through the CRR cross-reference
- K-CMG
- No
- K-NPR
- Any non-zero NPR rules out SNI
- K-CMG
- Any non-zero CMG rules out SNI
The K-CMG conditions
Article 23(1) lets the competent authority allow K-CMG only if all of these hold:
- The firm is not part of a group that contains a credit institution.
- Clearing and settlement take place under the responsibility of a clearing member of a qualifying CCP. That clearing member is a credit institution or a CRR investment firm, and the trades are centrally cleared or settled delivery-versus-payment under its responsibility.
- The total margin is calculated with the clearing member's margin model.
- The firm has shown that K-CMG is justified, for example because its main activities are trading subject to clearing and margining and its other activities are immaterial in comparison.
- The authority is satisfied that the choice of portfolio is not regulatory arbitrage.
The margin model must cover at least 99% of exposure movements over at least a two-business-day holding period, with prudence similar to the EMIR CCP margin rules. Article 23(3) mandates EBA regulatory technical standards on how the total margin and K-CMG are calculated, including on a portfolio basis; check the adopted standards with your competent authority.
A simple illustration
Suppose the clearing member called these total daily margins (EUR millions) over the last three months, and the five highest values were:
| Rank | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total margin required | 6.2 | 5.9 | 5.4 | 5.1 | 4.8 |
Illustrative figures.
- 1st
- 6.2
- 2nd
- 5.9
- 3rd
- 5.4
- 4th
- 5.1
- 5th
- 4.8
K-CMG = 3rd-highest × 1.3 = 5.4 × 1.3 = 7.02 → EUR 7.02 millionUsing the third-highest value ignores the two worst days, but the 1.3 factor and the clearing member's 99% model keep the charge prudent. The charge also lags: a margin observation affects K-CMG only if it changes the third-highest daily amount in the preceding three-month window.
When K-CMG tends to be lower, and when it isn't
- Hedged, cleared books. CCP margin models net across correlated contracts. For a spread or hedged futures book, clearing margin can be well below a standardised K-NPR, which is computed with fixed, conservative offsets.
- Directional books. For outright positions, margin can be close to or above K-NPR, and the 1.3 factor tips the balance.
- Volatile periods. Margin models react to market volatility. K-NPR on the standardised approach uses fixed risk weights rather than recalibrating them to daily volatility; positions, prices, FX and maturities still change the result.
- FRTB. K-CMG is not affected by the end of the IFR market-risk transitional on 1 January 2027. K-NPR is. See Does FRTB apply to investment firms?
What drives K-NPR on the standardised approach
Until the end of 2026, K-NPR on the standardised approach follows the CRR market-risk chapters as amended in 2019: position risk on debt and equity instruments (specific and general risk), foreign exchange risk on the net open position, and commodity risk. These are rule-based charges on positions, not on volatility, so risk weights are fixed while positions, prices, FX rates, maturities and netting can still change K-NPR daily. It is also blunt: offsets between related positions are recognised only where the rules allow, and a hedged book can carry a charge well above its economic risk. From 1 January 2027 the same Article 22 choice applies, against the CRR as it then stands. The details are in our FRTB go-live tracker.
Questions to ask your clearing member
- Can you provide the daily total margin required, per account and in total, in a machine-readable format?
- Which margin model do you use for each CCP and product, and how do you document its 99% coverage and holding period?
- How are add-ons (concentration, liquidity, credit) reflected in the total margin figure?
- Will you notify us in advance of margin model changes that could move our K-CMG?
Your competent authority will ask how you know the margin model stays prudent. Article 23(1) says it carries out a regular assessment, and the clearing member's answers are what you can show.
How to decide
- Check eligibility first: group structure, clearing arrangements and the share of cleared business.
- Compute both on the same dates for at least three months of history: K-NPR on your positions, K-CMG from the clearing member's daily margin reports.
- Look at the whole own funds requirement, not only the RtM K-factor. If fixed overheads bind, the choice may not matter.
- Weigh the operational side: K-CMG depends on your clearing member's data and model, and needs permission and monitoring.
- Document the reasoning for your competent authority. Article 23(1)(d) and (e) ask you to justify the choice.
Reporting
Both K-factors feed template I 04.00 (total K-factor requirement). The detail goes to I 06.09 for K-NPR and I 06.10 for K-CMG in the reporting set of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2021/2284. Since reference date 31 March 2026 the EBA accepts only xBRL-CSV on Euclid. National authorities set firms' collection formats and timetables; see our EBA reporting tracker.
Where Everix fits
Everix calculates FX and commodity K-NPR in the shared engine. Debt, equity and K-CON amounts are figures the firm attests. K-CMG needs competent-authority permission. The EBA xBRL-CSV pack covers all 44 active template codes. Try the K-factor calculator for a first view, or check whether you qualify as a small and non-interconnected firm with the Class 2/3 test.
Sources: Regulation (EU) 2019/2033, Articles 12, 21, 22, 23 and 57; Implementing Regulation (EU) 2021/2284. Figures are illustrative. General information, not regulatory advice.
Related on everix.io
The Everix note
Get the next article by email
IFR, CRR3, SIMM changes and AI-ready risk data. Roughly monthly, double opt-in.
More insights
SA-CCR worked example: EAD step by step
BCBS 279 Example 1 recomputed step by step: replacement cost 60, add-on 347, EAD 569. Supervisory duration, delta, hedging sets, multiplier and EU specifics.
K-TCD worked example: IFR counterparty capital
K-TCD under IFR Articles 25–32, step by step: replacement cost, PFE, collateral, risk factor and CVA factor, on two illustrative netting sets.