IFR/IFD · K-NPR · K-CMG

K-NPR vs K-CMG: which IFR market-risk K-factor?

· 7 min read · Everix team

Short answer: K-NPR measures the market risk of your positions with the CRR's market-risk approaches. K-CMG instead uses the margin your clearing member calls: the third-highest daily total margin of the last three months, times 1.3. K-CMG needs competent authority permission and only fits firms whose business is essentially cleared and margined trading. Everyone else uses K-NPR.

Both are Risk-to-Market K-factors under the Investment Firms Regulation. Article 21 says the RtM requirement is either K-NPR or K-CMG, and Article 23 allows K-CMG for all cleared positions or on a portfolio basis. A firm can therefore use K-CMG for a cleared portfolio and K-NPR for the rest.

Side by side

Legal basis
K-NPR
IFR Art. 22
K-CMG
IFR Art. 23
What it measures
K-NPR
Market risk of trading-book positions, plus non-trading-book FX and commodity positions (Art. 21(4))
K-CMG
Total margin required by the clearing member
Formula
K-NPR
CRR standardised approach, FRTB-SA or internal models
K-CMG
3rd-highest daily total margin over the preceding 3 months × 1.3
Permission
K-NPR
None for the standardised approach
K-CMG
Competent authority must allow it; regular review of the margin model
Scope
K-NPR
All trading-book positions not under K-CMG
K-CMG
All positions subject to clearing, or whole portfolios that are cleared or margined
Data you need
K-NPR
Positions, prices, and for FRTB-SA, sensitivities
K-CMG
Daily margin calls from the clearing member
Exposure to FRTB (2027)
K-NPR
Yes, through the CRR cross-reference
K-CMG
No
Effect on SNI (Class 3) status
K-NPR
Any non-zero NPR rules out SNI
K-CMG
Any non-zero CMG rules out SNI

The K-CMG conditions

Article 23(1) lets the competent authority allow K-CMG only if all of these hold:

  1. The firm is not part of a group that contains a credit institution.
  2. Clearing and settlement take place under the responsibility of a clearing member of a qualifying CCP. That clearing member is a credit institution or a CRR investment firm, and the trades are centrally cleared or settled delivery-versus-payment under its responsibility.
  3. The total margin is calculated with the clearing member's margin model.
  4. The firm has shown that K-CMG is justified, for example because its main activities are trading subject to clearing and margining and its other activities are immaterial in comparison.
  5. The authority is satisfied that the choice of portfolio is not regulatory arbitrage.

The margin model must cover at least 99% of exposure movements over at least a two-business-day holding period, with prudence similar to the EMIR CCP margin rules. Article 23(3) mandates EBA regulatory technical standards on how the total margin and K-CMG are calculated, including on a portfolio basis; check the adopted standards with your competent authority.

A simple illustration

Suppose the clearing member called these total daily margins (EUR millions) over the last three months, and the five highest values were:

Illustrative figures.

Total margin required
1st
6.2
2nd
5.9
3rd
5.4
4th
5.1
5th
4.8
K-CMG = 3rd-highest × 1.3 = 5.4 × 1.3 = 7.02  →  EUR 7.02 million

Using the third-highest value ignores the two worst days, but the 1.3 factor and the clearing member's 99% model keep the charge prudent. The charge also lags: a margin observation affects K-CMG only if it changes the third-highest daily amount in the preceding three-month window.

When K-CMG tends to be lower, and when it isn't

  • Hedged, cleared books. CCP margin models net across correlated contracts. For a spread or hedged futures book, clearing margin can be well below a standardised K-NPR, which is computed with fixed, conservative offsets.
  • Directional books. For outright positions, margin can be close to or above K-NPR, and the 1.3 factor tips the balance.
  • Volatile periods. Margin models react to market volatility. K-NPR on the standardised approach uses fixed risk weights rather than recalibrating them to daily volatility; positions, prices, FX and maturities still change the result.
  • FRTB. K-CMG is not affected by the end of the IFR market-risk transitional on 1 January 2027. K-NPR is. See Does FRTB apply to investment firms?

What drives K-NPR on the standardised approach

Until the end of 2026, K-NPR on the standardised approach follows the CRR market-risk chapters as amended in 2019: position risk on debt and equity instruments (specific and general risk), foreign exchange risk on the net open position, and commodity risk. These are rule-based charges on positions, not on volatility, so risk weights are fixed while positions, prices, FX rates, maturities and netting can still change K-NPR daily. It is also blunt: offsets between related positions are recognised only where the rules allow, and a hedged book can carry a charge well above its economic risk. From 1 January 2027 the same Article 22 choice applies, against the CRR as it then stands. The details are in our FRTB go-live tracker.

Questions to ask your clearing member

  • Can you provide the daily total margin required, per account and in total, in a machine-readable format?
  • Which margin model do you use for each CCP and product, and how do you document its 99% coverage and holding period?
  • How are add-ons (concentration, liquidity, credit) reflected in the total margin figure?
  • Will you notify us in advance of margin model changes that could move our K-CMG?

Your competent authority will ask how you know the margin model stays prudent. Article 23(1) says it carries out a regular assessment, and the clearing member's answers are what you can show.

How to decide

  1. Check eligibility first: group structure, clearing arrangements and the share of cleared business.
  2. Compute both on the same dates for at least three months of history: K-NPR on your positions, K-CMG from the clearing member's daily margin reports.
  3. Look at the whole own funds requirement, not only the RtM K-factor. If fixed overheads bind, the choice may not matter.
  4. Weigh the operational side: K-CMG depends on your clearing member's data and model, and needs permission and monitoring.
  5. Document the reasoning for your competent authority. Article 23(1)(d) and (e) ask you to justify the choice.

Reporting

Both K-factors feed template I 04.00 (total K-factor requirement). The detail goes to I 06.09 for K-NPR and I 06.10 for K-CMG in the reporting set of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2021/2284. Since reference date 31 March 2026 the EBA accepts only xBRL-CSV on Euclid. National authorities set firms' collection formats and timetables; see our EBA reporting tracker.

Where Everix fits

Everix calculates FX and commodity K-NPR in the shared engine. Debt, equity and K-CON amounts are figures the firm attests. K-CMG needs competent-authority permission. The EBA xBRL-CSV pack covers all 44 active template codes. Try the K-factor calculator for a first view, or check whether you qualify as a small and non-interconnected firm with the Class 2/3 test.

Sources: Regulation (EU) 2019/2033, Articles 12, 21, 22, 23 and 57; Implementing Regulation (EU) 2021/2284. Figures are illustrative. General information, not regulatory advice.

The Everix note

Get the next article by email

IFR, CRR3, SIMM changes and AI-ready risk data. Roughly monthly, double opt-in.

By subscribing, you ask for the Everix note. Confirm by email; unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Questions about your own portfolio?

Talk to the quants and engineers behind Everix — 30 minutes to check the fit.